Old School - Yellow Butter Cake with Chocolate American buttercream
Old School - Yellow Butter Cake with Chocolate American buttercream
Available September 2nd – November 28th
Meet your new fall favorite: the Old School Cake, a classic yellow butter cake soaked in sweet milk and layered with rich chocolate American buttercream. This nostalgic birthday cake recipe brings back the timeless taste of an old-fashioned American birthday cake — perfect for fall birthdays and seasonal celebrations.
Customize your cake with colorful, all-natural sprinkles for a playful, nostalgic finish, or a fresh floral posy for an elevated look. Add a personalized message to make it a truly custom birthday cake.
Party Extras
Party Cakes
Perfect for birthdays, holidays, and everyday celebrations, our Party Cakes are available in five signature flavors and several frosting styles, plus a rotating selection of seasonal flavors and designs. Available to order 2 - 60 days in advance.
FAQs
A list of ingredients for each flavor in our current line-up can be viewed here.
Party Cakes must be pre-ordered a minimum of 2 days and a maximum of 60 days in advance of your desired pick-up date. If you need a quicker turn-around, check out our Next-Day Cake collection.
For our signature Party Cakes, we unfortunately cannot accommodate requests for specific flowers/floral colors. For more floral customization options, please browse our Special Occasion Cake collection or submit a Custom Cake Inquiry.
To help us manage the volume of orders we receive, any and all requests for modifications must be submitted as a Custom Inquiry. We appreciate your understanding!
Local delivery is available via DoorDash within 5 miles of our shop for a $20 delivery fee. Due to the volume of orders we receive, we cannot guarantee precise delivery times within your selected delivery window. We appreciate your understanding!
